Is it OK if I decide to use the leftover coffee to brew a new pot of coffee? I would have to add some water as well, so the old coffee would be watered down.
Would this be a problem for my coffee maker? Could it do any damage?
Would the new coffee have more caffeine than normal? I'm guessing taste would suffer, but in what ways?
I couldn’t help but smile at your question. 😁
How to make a coffee geek squirm!
I’ve never done what you’re suggesting. But in the summer I’ll sometimes keep leftover coffee in the fridge so I can use it to make iced coffee. (Not to be confused with cold-brew coffee.)
That said, I can’t think of a compelling reason why you shouldn’t “re-brew” some coffee from time to time.
It will make the secondary brew stronger, so long as you use the same amount of coffee as usual. And yes, a bit more caffeine.
Mess with the taste? Absolutely! If I were doing this, I’d only do it with a really ordinary coffee… and never with a really good gourmet coffee.
Will it damage your coffee maker? Probably not, so long as it’s just the coffee you’re re-brewing, and not with milk and or sugar!
One note of caution. It could become a bit of a health hazard over time.
When your brewer completes a cycle, there is still water left in the system, particularly in the pump.
If you’re re-brewing coffee, that means some coffee will be left sitting in the brewer for the next 24 hours at least. And guess what loves a warm, wet and dark environment? Bacteria! And yes, bacteria are happy to grow in coffee.
So… if you want to re-brew, maybe do it every other day. On the other days, use plain water to flush out the system and keep it clean.
That said… as a coffee lover… I never have and never would re-brew old coffee for myself. 🙂
Thanks for the unusual question!
Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Questions about Coffee.
Sign up for occasional newsletters about the best coffees and brewing equipment. Plus special updates from the Coffee Detective Coffee Store…